[Karin]

I joined here hoping to be able to discuss about SH but upon seeing that there's no thread on the SH section I got really disappointed.
So which one is your favorite SH game?

*I did not add Koudelka because I don't consider it a SH game,although I do know that it plays quite a big role in SH1.

[Koby]

Okay, first Shadow Hearts was great, by far the top game in the series.

The second lacked key aspects and just didn't seem right.

The third in my opinion was overall better than the second, but should have been a different game, it didn't feel like it should be within the Shadow Hearts series.

Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed all three games and played every one of them multiple times to unlock everything and do all sidequests, etc.. it's just neither of the sequels ever came close to being as great as the first.

[Karin]

It usually is like that.But since the first one I played was SH:Covenant so it holds a special place in my heart.

[lucky.clover287]

the best one for me is shadow hearts from the new world... it's better from the 2..
but i also like the covenant.